Claim 10 of 13 · Case 04 · The Trinity

The New Testament identifies the Holy Spirit with God directly, not just as a person but as one who shares in what only God is.

One claim from the free evidence repository at apologetics.pro.

Suggest a correction

A person can still be a creature. What pushes the Spirit onto the divine side of that line is a smaller body of evidence than what exists for Jesus, and that should be said plainly rather than papered over. But it is there, and it converges from more than one direction: an apostle equating the Spirit with God outright, properties handed to the Spirit that no creature can hold, and a ranking of sins that only makes sense if the Spirit stands where God stands.

Backed by 4 pieces of evidence

  1. Lying to the Spirit is lying to God, Acts 5:3-4

    This is not devotion or worship language, which can flex a little in meaning. It is an accusation, stated once against the Spirit and restated against God, with nothing in the text marking a shift in who is actually being wronged.

    1 source · 1 objection

  2. Attributes that belong to God alone are applied to the Spirit

    None of these are borrowed roles. A creature can be sent somewhere, told something, or given power for a time. A creature cannot itself be present everywhere, know all things without being told, or exist without ever having begun.

    3 sources · 1 objection

  3. An unforgivable sin, aimed at the Spirit rather than the Son, Matthew 12:31-32

    Jesus himself is the highest figure in the passage up to that point. Naming an offense against the Spirit as graver than one against himself only holds together if the Spirit belongs beside God rather than beneath him.

    1 source · 1 objection

  4. The Spirit proceeds from the Father and is sent in the Son’s name, John 15:26 and John 14:26

    “Sent” language on its own could describe any messenger and wouldn’t get this claim very far, an angel is sent too. What matters here is the word alongside it: “proceeds from” describes the Spirit’s origin as within the Father’s own life, the same kind of internal relation the earlier claim on the Son uses for “life in himself” (John 5:26), rather than a creature being dispatched from outside. A being who proceeds from God’s own being, rather than being made and then sent, is described the way Scripture describes God, not the way it describes a creature.

    2 sources · 1 objection