Claim 8 of 13 · Case 04 · The Trinity

The New Testament treats the Holy Spirit as a person who acts, not as an impersonal force or energy.

One claim from the free evidence repository at apologetics.pro.

Suggest a correction
Some passages talk about being filled with the Spirit, or the Spirit being poured out, which can sound like a substance or a power rather than a someone. That language is genuinely there. But it is not the whole picture, and the rest of the picture is hard to square with a mere force. Over and over the Spirit does things only a person does. He speaks. He decides. He can be lied to. He chooses. A force does not do any of that.

Backed by 3 pieces of evidence

  1. The Spirit speaks and commissions, Acts 13:2

    The phrase “for me” is the key. A force has no self to act for. The Spirit speaks as an “I” with a mission, which is the behavior of a person.

    1 source · 1 objection

  2. Lying to the Spirit is lying to God, Acts 5:3-4

    This does double duty. It shows the Spirit is personal, because you cannot lie to a power, and it equates the Spirit with God in the same breath. Personhood and deity land together.

    1 source · 1 objection

  3. The Spirit forbids, chooses, and can be grieved, Acts 16:6-7, 1 Corinthians 12:11, Ephesians 4:30

    Taken together these answer the force objection directly. Forbidding, willing, and being grieved are not things an energy does. They are things a person does.

    3 sources · 2 objections