apologetics.pro

Claim 6 of 8 · Case 06 · Problem of Evil

Scripture ties genuine love and obedience to genuine choice, which supports the idea that a world of free creatures is worth its risks.

One claim from the free evidence repository at apologetics.pro.

Suggest a correction
We argue that real love has to be chosen, not forced, and that this is part of why God made creatures who could turn away from him. Scripture does not lay this out as a formal argument, and this is the most debated claim in the Christian answer, because Christians themselves disagree about how human freedom and God’s sovereignty fit together. What scripture does clearly do is show God setting real choices before people, commanding love rather than compelling it, and holding people responsible for what they choose. That pattern fits a world where love is chosen. It is offered here as support, not as proof, and the honest counterweight is included below.

Backed by 4 pieces of evidence

  1. The book of Deuteronomy, the choice set before Israel

    God deals with people here as choosers. The whole scene assumes the outcome is genuinely up to them, which is the pattern the free-will reading depends on: responsibility only makes sense if the choice is real.

    1 source · 2 objections

  2. The book of Joshua, choosing whom to serve

    This adds a second clear case of scripture treating devotion as chosen. One passage alone could be brushed off as a figure of speech, but a repeated pattern across different books is harder to dismiss, and that pattern is what this argument leans on.

    1 source · 1 objection

  3. The Gospel of Matthew, the great commandment

    If God commands love, then love must be something a person can choose to offer or refuse, since a forced or programmed affection would not be worth commanding. That is the exact point: real love needs real choice.

    1 source · 2 objections

  4. Passages on God’s sovereignty, the honest counterweight

    Fairness means naming the other side too, not just winning the point. The free will reading is real and well supported, but it is not the only strand in scripture. The Bible holds human choice and God’s sovereignty together in a tension that Christians have resolved in different ways for centuries. Take the free will reading as one fair way to see it, not as the settled meaning of the whole Bible.

    2 sources · 1 objection

Read it in contextAll 8 claims in this case