Objection · Case 12 · Jehovah’s Witnesses

Witnesses reply that lying to God’s active force is lying to God because the force is God’s, as lying to a king’s edict is lying to the king. The verse identifies the Spirit with God; it doesn’t make the Spirit a person.

One objection from the free evidence repository at apologetics.pro.

Suggest a correction

Response

Acts 5 primarily establishes the Spirit’s deity, and personhood comes from the wider pattern; this verse should not be asked to carry more than it gives. The lying to a force point is suggestive rather than decisive on its own. Personification of wisdom or sin is a real biblical device, but it is occasional and poetic, whereas the Spirit speaks, decides, forbids, is lied to, intercedes, and is called another Advocate by Jesus (John 14:16) in parallel to himself, across narrative, letter, and liturgy. A consistent pattern of personal action across genres is what the argument rests on.

About this exhibit

This objection is to The Acts of the Apostles, chapter 5, verses 3 to 4.

Peter tells Ananias he has lied to the Holy Spirit, then says, “You have not lied to men but to God.”

Under Claim 09: The New Testament describes the Holy Spirit doing things only a person can do, which does not fit an impersonal force.